Superior, Wisconsin

Discover the rental home you've been looking for

From cozy apartments to spacious family homes, we manage rental properties across Superior that feel like home from day one — with responsive service that actually shows up when you need it.

Browse Properties Get in Touch
15+
Years Managing
100+
Happy Tenants
Superior
WI Community
Charming rental home in Superior, Wisconsin
New Listing
Just added

3-bed home near Lake Superior with modern finishes.

Scroll
Our Listings

Find Your Next Place

Browse our carefully managed rental properties in and around Superior. Each home is maintained to the highest standard so you can focus on what matters.

Spacious apartment with lake views
Apartment

Downtown Loft Apartment

2 bed · 1 bath · 950 sq ft

Walk to the waterfront, shops, and restaurants in this bright downtown unit with exposed brick and updated kitchen.

Inquire Now
Family home with backyard
House

North End Family Home

3 bed · 2 bath · 1,400 sq ft

Quiet neighborhood near top-rated schools. Features a finished basement, updated bathrooms, and a fenced yard.

Inquire Now
Townhome near the lake
Townhome

Lakeview Townhome

2 bed · 1.5 bath · 1,100 sq ft

Short drive to the lakefront with panoramic views. Open floor plan, in-unit laundry, and a private patio.

Inquire Now
View All Available Rentals
Street view in Superior, Wisconsin
Scenic view of Lake Superior near Superior
Cozy interior of a rental property
Exterior of a well-maintained rental home
Since 2009
Serving Superior, WI
About Us

Rooted in Superior.
Committed to You.

Mahan Rental Properties was founded on a simple belief: renting a home should feel secure, straightforward, and genuinely pleasant. We've spent over a decade building that experience in Superior and the surrounding Douglas County communities.

Whether you're searching for your first apartment, a place to raise a family, or a low-maintenance property near the lake, we match you with homes that fit your life — not just your budget. Our properties are individually maintained, and our response times speak for themselves.

For property owners, we bring the same care to your investment. From tenant placement to routine inspections and timely rent collection, we treat your home like it's our own.

Responsive Maintenance
Issues addressed within 24 hours
Local Expertise
Deep knowledge of the area
Transparent Terms
No hidden fees, clear leases
Well-Maintained Homes
Regular inspections & care
What We Do

Services Built Around You

Whether you're looking to rent or need help managing a property, we offer full-spectrum services tailored to the Superior market.

Tenant Placement

We screen applicants thoroughly, handle lease signing, and ensure every new tenant is set up for a smooth move-in — so you spend less time worrying and more time enjoying.

Property Management

From collecting rent to coordinating repairs, we handle the day-to-day so property owners can relax. Regular inspections keep your investment in top shape year-round.

Lease Administration

Clear, fair lease agreements that protect both parties. We handle renewals, move-out procedures, and everything in between with professionalism and transparency.

Maintenance Coordination

When something breaks, it gets fixed fast. We maintain a network of trusted local contractors and respond to service requests within 24 hours — no runaround.

Rent Collection

On-time payments, every month. We handle billing, follow-ups, and financial reporting so property owners have a clear picture of their rental income.

Tenant Support

Questions about your lease? Need to request a repair? We're always reachable by phone or email and treat every tenant with respect and urgency.

Testimonials

What Our Residents Say

Real feedback from people who chose to call Superior home through Mahan Rental Properties.

"Moving to Superior felt daunting until I found Mahan Rental. They made the whole process effortless — from the first call to getting my keys. The apartment was exactly as described, and any issue I've had was handled the same day."

S
Sarah M.
Apartment Resident · Superior, WI

"As a property owner, I've worked with a few management companies over the years. Mahan stands out because they actually communicate — monthly statements, proactive updates, and tenants who stay long-term. My vacancy rate has never been lower."

R
Robert D.
Property Owner · Douglas County

"We've rented from Mahan for three years now and wouldn't go anywhere else. The homes are well-kept, the neighborhood is perfect for our kids, and the office team treats us like people, not just rent checks. That matters more than you'd think."

J
Jennifer L.
Family Resident · Superior, WI

Ready to Find Your
Perfect Rental?

Whether you're a prospective tenant or a property owner, we'd love to hear from you. Reach out today and let's start the conversation.

Schedule a Viewing (715) 394-4062
Get in Touch

Let's Start a
Conversation

Have a question about an available property, need to submit a maintenance request, or want to discuss listing your home with us? We're here and happy to help.

Office Address
320 Baxter Ave
Superior, WI 54880-1238
Office Hours
Monday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday: By Appointment
Sunday: Closed

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within one business day.

Is this your business?This is my business